That same day, shares slid by over 7%. And, as you can see below, shares are down by around 8% since April 22.
On Thursday, April 28, MPW announced its Q1-22 earnings. And during its conference call, CEO Edward Aldag explained (emphasis added):
“In my overall remarks today, I will also take time to address a few other points that have been raised in recent reports and media coverage about [us]. While we typically don’t respond to the various third-party reports of this nature and some of this information may seem like real estate one-on-one, we have heard from many of you, our shareholders, and others that we should take the opportunity to set the record straight and correct some of the erroneous information that has been published.” (Emphasis added.)
Clearly, frustrations are mounting for MPW. That much is obvious, based on how shares have dropped over 22% year-to-date. Whereas, the Vanguard Real Estate Index Fund (VNQ) is only down 10%.
MPW Isn’t Stacking Up (At Least In This Regard)
Most of MPW’s peers have outperformed it, except for CareTrust REIT (CTRE), as seen below:
One of MPW’s most notable challenges is to grow its business by utilizing its cheapest forms of capital. And, of course, common equity is not one of them.
With an equity multiple of 7.6%, it’s difficult for MPW to invest in new healthcare properties. As such, it must resort to other methods. Consider what CFO R. Steven Hamner said about his company:
“… we have estimated a range of accretive acquisitions in 2022 of between $1 billion and $3 billion. We are confident the investment opportunities are there. But the ultimate volume this year will be related to the amount and timing of our access to attractively priced equity capital.” (Emphasis added.)
It’s also important to note how management doesn’t like its current equity pricing. It made that clear on the call. This dynamic could cause MPW to acquire only a portion of the $4 billion to $5 billion of opportunities it otherwise could.
As it is, to help finance current acquisition expectations, the company must sell assets and various joint ventures. Fortunately, MPW has a good history of using JVs – including the recent 50% stake it sold in a $1.7 billion Steward portfolio to Macquarie Asset Management. (Incidentally, Steward is still its largest tenant.)
It’s also provided us with some new transparency in hopes of clearing up some of the “erroneous information” out there. Needless to say, this could help it return to its previous valuation level.
In which case, it would issue equity to generate attractive investment spreads. The kind of numbers we’d be happy to be part of.
Medical Properties Trust’s Management Provides Some Clarity
On last week’s earnings call, Medical Properties Trust defended claims regarding straight-line rent write-offs and Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) coverage ratio comparisons.
Detailed tenant disclosures are important for investors to be able to look over. And I’ve often challenged MPW to provide more transparency in that regard. So, I’m happy to see it offer details about its top five.
This new color on key operators should be very helpful for analysts and investors – especially given the fact that most all its tenants are citing some signs of improvement. For example:
- Steward’s reported coverage was 2.8x
- Median was 1.9x
- Prime was 5.2x
- Priory was 1.8x
- Springstone was 1.5x.
Aldag explained on the Q1-22 earnings call (emphasis added):
“First, let me point out as I have numerous times, EBITDARM [earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, amortization, rent, and management fees] in these calculations come straight from property level GAAP basis financial reports we received from our tenants, which include their annual audited financials at year-end.
“Except an extremely rare or unusual circumstances such as the COVID grants for 2020 and 2021, and some minor immaterial prior period updates, no adjustments have been made to these numbers.
“These EBITDARM numbers are trailing 12 months for the period ending 12/31/21. We use earnings before interest, depreciation, amortization, rent and management fees, and the actual cash rent amounts owed to [MPW].” (Emphasis added.)
That’s worth exploring more, so let’s do precisely that…
More From The MPW’s Mouth
Aldag also added (emphasis added):
“There have been a couple of recent reports from third parties outside of the company that have tried to use CMS cost report NOI [net operating income] numbers to show profit margins and equate that to a lease coverage comparison. CMS uses different definitions and allows different deductions for items such as depreciation, amortization, interest, and other items than what is required in GAAP financial statements.
“Furthermore, they include all rental and lease payments and interest payments among other items. Therefore, when quoting the profit margins, one must keep in mind that all [MPW] rent and other rent and interest has already been accounted for in those numbers. By definition, the CMS cost reports could actually show a negative profit margin and all of the rent and interest being paid at the same time.”
This comment is specifically related to a short report where an analyst used CMS-reported NOI to make lease coverage comparisons.
However, as Aldag pointed out, CMS uses different definitions to calculate such ratios. So the cost it reports imply negative profit margins for all operators… which is negated by EBITDARM coverage ratios.
In regard to Steward, which amounts to 19.2% of its total portfolio, MPW explained:
“Steward has kept coverage ratios at or above the industry standard and has remained flat close to an almost 3x coverage for the past three quarters. One item of note is that the recent acquisitions in the Miami region continue to far exceed our original expectations.
“And just as a reminder, the HCA Utah transaction is projected to close by the end of the second quarter of this year. Notwithstanding the value we have generated from Steward being one of our tenants, Steward accounts for an increasingly smaller portion of our portfolio as we continue to invest domestically and internationally in non-Steward hospitals.”
Notably, salary wages and contract labor are also well below budget. And utility/food costs have not experienced hugely incremental impact from inflationary pressures.
Medical Properties Trust Q1 Earnings Results
For Q1-22, MPW generated normalized funds from operations (FFO) of $0.47 per diluted share. Meanwhile, full-year 2022 guidance was $1.78-$1.82 per share.
The hospital REIT changed how it presents FFO guidance to provide more transparency over its acquisition pipeline. As noted, it’s providing an investment volume of $1 billion to $3 billion in 2022…
Or $4 billion to $5 billion if it can improve its equity cost of capital.
That’s part of why MPW’s cost of capital is considered at risk and why shares have pulled back. And then the “erroneous information” published has put more pressure on shares still.
But that’s just created a better buying opportunity for you and me.
We all know valuation is more of an art. But as a REIT scientist, I like to utilize all available data and resources anyway.
Let’s start with MPW and its healthcare peers’ p/FFO:
And their dividend yields:
We’ve been following MPW for around a decade. So I must credit management for its underwriting acumen.
It always maintains discipline to drive strong FFO performance, despite industry pressures.
Plus, labor issues seem to be improving for MPW’s tenants. And even if they don’t this quarter, MPW says its operators should withstand the pressure until CMS adjusts Medicare rates to sufficiently offset inflation.
(Their current portfolio EBITDARM rent coverage ratio is 2.7x.)
Yes, the next set of quarterly coverage ratios could be down slightly thanks to labor pressures January-February. But MPW’s tenants collectively saw signs of improvement in March-April.
That’s why I want to thank all that “erroneous information.” It has allowed me to buy more shares on the cheap.
Shares now yield 6.3%, and our price target is $27… which translates into a total 12-month return forecast of 45%.
We just loaded up the truck…. beep beep… Thank you, Mr. Market!!!